Welcome to Colosseum Pizza
Colosseum New York Pizza, located in Milpitas, CA, is a well-loved pizza joint known for its made-to-order pizzas with generous toppings. Customers rave about the New York-style pizza, especially the flavorful mushroom and Italian sausage combo. The family-friendly atmosphere and accommodating staff make dining in a pleasant experience. With a wide range of vegetarian and non-vegetarian options, including cheesesteaks and sandwiches, this veteran-owned establishment offers a convenient food delivery service. Although some customers have noted slightly higher prices for certain items, the overall quality of food and service at Colosseum New York Pizza consistently receives high praise. A must-try for pizza lovers in the area!
Colosseum Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
The pizza here is made to order and has a healthy amount of toppings.
This joint is more for takeout rather than a sit down as seat are limited.
Overall great place to check out for a good slice of NY style pizza!
Colosseum pizza is definitely a family favorite! We have been going here for years and it has never disappointed us once. My personal favorite is the New York- it has mushrooms and Italian sausage on top. It's so good! Definitely give this place a shot:
Came here on Sunday for lunch with my cousin and was not disappointed! Tony and Rose were very accommodating when it came to dine-in. The all meat pizza was excellent and came fresh out the oven to us. Overall, it was a great experience and I will be back with more friends!
Got this for our team the other day. My friend, who is originally from the East Coast, said this pizza came very close to the pies from her childhood and was pleasantly surprised at the quality for a NY style pizza out here, which she doesn't find much. The team requested we use this place moving forward.
Can't get a better review than that!
My go to pizza in Milpitas for years. Always good, always delicious and quick pickup.
I can't give this place any higher than 4 out of 5 star review. I ordered medium combo pizza, garlic knots and Caesar salad. To my surprise, they charged over $3 for a small portion of anchovies and $7 for Caesar salad. For $7.00 I would expect would be more but instead it looked like 4 Romaine lettuce blades chopped, croutons and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese with a small container of Caesar salad dressing. Don't get me wrong, their pizza was DELISH and that I completely support the mom & pop businesses but I don't support business that charge every grain of salt used in a dish. If I do go back to this pizza joint, it will be ONLY for pizza. I give 5 stars to businesses that provide exceptional customer service, reasonable prices and exceptional food quality. This was a border between 3 to 4 stars but their pizza was VERY good so I am giving them 4 stars.
Price: $$ - $$$
Quality: A +
Service: A
Got a large corporate order with multiple vegetarian and non vegetarian pizzas. Good selection and good pizza.
If you're looking for a reliable and efficient food delivery service, look no further than Colosseum New York Pizza! I've been a loyal customer for months now, and I'm always impressed by their professionalism. They take care to ensure that my orders arrive promptly and in perfect condition. The menu selection is extensive, catering to various dietary preferences, and the quality of the food is exceptional. Colosseum New York Pizza has definitely become my go-to choice for convenient and tasty meals at home. Give them a try--you won't be disappointed!
Can't recommend this slice house enough!
Staff: 10/10
Pizza: 10/10
Cannoli cream flown in from Brooklyn: 100/10
My uncle from NY initially recommended this spot, and it did not disappoint. There's a lot of different types of pies, so I suggest ordering (over the phone) half and half pizzas so you can try it all!
The cannoli IMMEDIATELY transported me back to my first one in New York and I'm definitely going back for more. The staff was so nice and accommodating when we picked up, I could tell that they were grateful for our patronage. It's in a small shopping plaza that gets looked over -- pro tip: don't look over it.
Location
-
761 E Capitol Ave Milpitas, CA 95035 Hotline: (408) 262-8633
Welcome to Colosseum New York Pizza! As the owner, I take great pride in serving the finest Cheesesteaks, Pizza, and Sandwiches in Milpitas, CA. Our brand is built on providing exceptional food quality, outstanding customer service, and a welcoming atmosphere.
At Colosseum New York Pizza, we prioritize taking care of our customers. Whether you choose to dine in, order takeout, or have your meal delivered, we strive to exceed your expectations. Our menu boasts a wide variety of options, including vegan and vegetarian choices, ensuring there is something for everyone. We also offer the convenience of online reservations and accept various payment methods, including credit cards, Android Pay, and Apple Pay.
One of the highlights of our pizzeria is our New York style pizza. Made to order and generously topped, our pizzas are a crowd favorite. Customers like Raymond L. and Amber B. have raved about our pizzas, emphasizing the healthy amount of toppings and delicious flavors. Their reviews echo the sentiments of many others who regard us as their go-to place for pizza.
In addition to our mouthwatering pizzas, we offer an extensive menu that includes cheesesteaks, sandwiches, and salads. Our dedicated team ensures that every item is prepared with the finest ingredients and utmost care. Customers like Peter T. and Trish B. have shared their positive experiences, emphasizing the excellent quality and taste of our food.
We are not just a place for food enthusiasts, but also a place for community support. As a veteran-owned business, we take pride in serving our customers and giving back to the community we cherish. Our comfortable and casual seating, as well as amenities like outdoor seating and Wi-Fi, create a warm and inviting environment for families, friends, and colleagues to come together and enjoy a meal.
Located at 761 E Capitol Ave, Milpitas, CA, we are easily accessible with ample private lot parking and bike parking options. You can reach us at (408) 262-8633 to make a reservation or inquire about our services.
We are passionate about providing exceptional customer service and strive to make each visit to Colosseum New York Pizza a memorable one. Our customers' satisfaction means everything to us, and we are thrilled to have such positive feedback from patrons like Warren T., Deepika R., Alyson C., and Welly M. Their reviews reflect our commitment to delivering delicious food and a seamless dining experience.
So, whether you're craving a classic New York style pizza, a mouthwatering cheesesteak, or a delectable sandwich, we invite you to join us at Colosseum New York Pizza. We promise not only exceptional food but also a dining experience that will keep you coming back for more. Come and discover for yourself why we are the top choice for pizza in Milpitas!
